top of page
Writer's pictureMike Hart

Understanding Insurance Deductibles: Bigger Isn't Always Better

Updated: Sep 19

Blurred background depicting a car accident with visible damage to the vehicles. Foreground shows a piggy bank and repair tools, symbolizing the cost savings and potential expenses associated with high deductibles. The image uses a calming color scheme of blues and greens with accents of red and orange.

In today’s challenging economy, where prices are rising and budgets are tighter than ever, many insurance brokers are quickly shifting towards raising deductibles as a means to reduce premiums. But what does this actually mean for you as a consumer? Let's break it down.


The Cost of Raising Deductibles


While increasing your deductible from $500 to $1,000 might save you a couple hundred dollars a year, it’s essential to consider the real cost of that decision. On a monthly basis, a $200 annual savings translates to less than $20 in your pocket each month. While this might feel like a win, the implications can be significant if you find yourself in an accident.

For high-risk or new drivers, a higher deductible might make sense in specific scenarios. The savings can accumulate over the years, potentially covering that additional cost if no accidents occur. However, if that $20 savings is crucial for your financial stability, ask yourself: how easily could you come up with $1,000 if your vehicle needs repairs?


A Lesson from My Early Days


When I was younger and shopping for insurance, no one took the time to explain coverages, deductibles, or what they meant for me. I remember being asked about liability limits and whether I wanted collision or comprehensive coverage. I had no idea what they were talking about, and it felt like everyone was too busy to slow down and answer my questions.


In my quest for the cheapest premium, I made the mistake of choosing a higher deductible option without fully understanding the implications. When claim time came, I realized how significant that decision was. Back then, it would have been a stretch to come up with $250, but I was suddenly faced with a $500 deductible because of my earlier choice.


Today, I see co-workers increasing client deductibles to $1,500. While the clients might feel happy about their immediate savings, I worry for them. Sure, they may never need to access their coverage, but accidents happen. If they’re deemed at fault—or even partially at fault—they could find themselves in a tough spot, unable to afford repairs.


The Bottom Line


Accidents are called accidents for a reason. You can do everything right, yet still find yourself in an unexpected situation. While saving money today may seem appealing, consider the potential long-term implications of raising your deductible. It’s not just about the immediate savings; it’s about being prepared for the unexpected.

If you’re uncertain about your current deductible or coverage options, I encourage you to reach out. As the owner of Switch Insurance in Sherwood Park, I’m here to help you navigate these important decisions. Understanding your insurance is key to protecting your financial future.


Have you faced a situation where a higher deductible impacted your ability to cover costs? Share your experiences below!

3 views0 comments

Recent Posts

See All

Σχόλια


bottom of page